No one onMarried At First Sightseason 18 is more deceitful than Madison Myers, who shocked everyone by confessing her feelings for Michelle Tomblin’s husband, David Trimble—proving she had deceived her cast mates and the experts. It is no secret thatMarried At First Sightseason 18has been filled with drama. Still, the biggest issue has been the high rate of mismatched couples— particularly Madison and Allen Slovick and Michelle and David. From the start, Michelle and David lacked chemistry. But that wasn’t the case for Madison and Allen, who initially seemed like a great fit.
They shared similar values, a mutual desire for family and stability, similar career aspirations, and complementary personalities, making them look like a rareMAFSsuccess story. Madison and Allen’s drama-free honeymoon only reinforced that impression. However, things took a turn whenMadison admitted Allen wasn’t her type, something she never moved past. It was clear Madison and David had much more in common than their original partners. The recent episode ofMadison confessing her feelings towards David wasn’t entirely surprising. It confirmed that Madison had been stringing Allen along the entire time.
Madison Was Never Interested In Allen
Madison Was Playing Games & Gaslighting Allen The Entire Season
Although their romance started strong,Madison hid her true feelings for Allen. Their relationship was defined by Madison’s lack of chemistry with him. This led the couple into an awkward conversation about her lack of attraction. She slammed him for his loud outfits and even said she liked gym freaks and men prioritizing self-care. Her comments were hurtful to Allen, as they implied he didn’t meet her physical standards of beauty.
Madison, 29, also noted she had previously dated “pretty boys”—well-groomed, clean-shaven, and athletic-looking men. ThroughoutMAFSseason 18, Madison’s behavior towards Allen has been inconsistent. While she made it clear that theMarried At First Sightcast memberwasn’t her type, Madison also contradicted herself sometimes, suggesting that it wasn’t an issue, ultimately giving him mixed signals. On the other hand, Allen remained consistent in his efforts to make their marriage work.
He has been patient and kind and seems to have good situational awareness. In contrast, Madison has been superficial, believing she might be better off with someone else.While it is understandable that a person participating in a dating experiment likeMAFSmight lack attraction towards their partner, that doesn’t justify treating them as less than human, which is what Madison has been doing with Allen. Her greatest problem was dragging him along and trying to change him while she didn’t intend to play her role in trying to make their marriage work.
Madison Was Plotting Behind The Experts & Her Cast Mates' Backs
They Were All Blindsided
Besides having similar hobbies, it was pretty clearMadison and David were talking and meeting off-camera,something Michelle eventually caught on to. While it was inappropriate, theseMarried At First Sightcast members were working out together and building a friendship instead of working on their marriages, which made the situation worse. In previous episodes,Michelle started noticing David’s inconsistenciesafter she caught him texting a mother woman:
“You’re so damn fine, I just wanna eat U up.”
When Michelle asked David about the text, he claimed it was intended for his older cousin. Later, she confessed to Emem Obot thatshe suspected the text message was meant for Madison. During dinner at thecouple’s retreat, Michelle confronted Madison, who walked away, annoyed, while David denied the accusations. InMarried At First Sightseason 18,Madison came across as a villainfor leading Allen on and lying to Michelle when she confronted her.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
She deceived everyone, including theMAFSexperts. The fact that she signed up for theMAFSexperiment meant she was ready to marry a stranger. If Madison was unhappy with her match, she would have handled the situation more maturely rather than being too critical of Allen at all times. Rather than taking a thoughtful approach like going through theMAFSstintwhile reflecting on herself, growing, and waiting until Decision Day, Madison chose to use the sledgehammer approach, which has ultimately damaged her reputation.
How Madison’s Cheating Has Affected MAFS Season 18
It Has Broken Genuine Friendships
There are many ways Madison’s cheating will affectMAFSseason 18, such as new couples emerging. Since Madison and David connected separately, Allen and Michelle might end up together for the remaining episodes ofMarried At First Sight. However, trust will also be broken,with the friendship between Allen and David now tainted with betrayal. The two had a conversation about what happened, and a heartbroken Allen told David that Madison had played him. In the clip above, Allen admitted that he considered David a friend, making the situation even more painful (viamafslifetime).
“Number one, I saw you as a friend.”
In his justification, David said Madison was a friend who gave him a space to share his struggles with Michelle:
“We talk, she knows more about me than my wife.”
While expressing his disappointment at David’s revelation that he grew close to Madison, Allen asked if David saw a future with Madison, to which he responded:
“Yes, I will be 100 with you.”
Although Michelle and Allen haven’t interacted as much as their original partners,it’s possible they could get along. Unlike David, Allen is more financially stable, something Michelle values in her partner. They might also bond over their shared trauma, providing support for one another. Also, Allen seemed more committed to the experience than David. Initially, Michelle told the experts she was looking for someone more committed to the experience. Given how much effort Allen put into his relationship with Madison, he seems willing to see if things work out with someone before the finale.
Madison and David seem more compatible, which begs the question of why didn’t the experts put them together in the first place. However, they are both terrible liars who struggled to keep their stories straight, making them the driving force towards the couple’s swap and thecheating scandal inMAFSseason 18. This casts doubts on the show and might make the viewers questionthe experts' credibility in providing successful matches. It would also make others question if the participants have genuine intentions of joining the show.
Can Madison Redeem Her Reputation?
It Might Be Too Late
Madison has been nothing but mean towards Allen onMarried At First Sight.She criticized his sense of style from the start, making it clear she wanted him to be more polished and trendy. Yet, Madison seemed to have gravitated towards David, who looked like the type of man she wanted Allen to be. With Madison’s admission about her feelings towards David being made clear, any chance of redemption is long gone. Initially, Madison and David were gym buddies, but their friendship seems to have evolved into something more.
In her confession, Madison said she liked David more than she should, admitting she couldn’t continue with her marriage. The fact that thisMarried At First Sightreality star entertained a relationship with someone else while she was still married to Allen proves she was never invested in him—and never intended to be. Her behavior was downright manipulative on her part, especially on the days she would act like she was okay with their marriage. At this point, redemption might be out of reach for Madison, who takes the title of a classic villain this season.
Married At First Sightairs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. EST on Lifetime.
Married At First Sight
Cast
Based on the Danish version of the series, Married at First Sight is a reality show/social experiment that gives singles a chance to find a lifelong partnership with one particular caveat: they must agree to marry a stranger arranged the moment they meet. Experts provide counseling and guidance as they help couples navigate their new marriage with their unknown partner and highlight the journey of the newlyweds from wedding to honeymoon to beginning their new lives together. At the end of eight weeks, couples will decide to stay married or divorce.
