Catelyn Stark meets a tragic end inGame of Thronesseason 3, buther death would have been worse withGeorge R.R. Martin’s original plan. Martin’sSong of Ice and Firebookshaven’t revealed the fates of all his characters just yet, but Catelyn and Robb Stark perish fairly early in the series — and in a very similar way to their book counterparts. Both characters dying at the Red Wedding may have come as a surprise to TV-only fans, but those familiar with Martin’s series knew it was coming.
And although Catelyn’s death at the hands of the Freys, Boltons, and Lannisters is pretty gruesome, it’s nothing compared to what she could have faced.Martin’s originalGame of Thronesplan saw a handful of storylines playing out much differentlythan they do in the books and show. From Sansa and Joffrey having a child toJaime Lannister claiming the Iron Throne, Martin’s initial outline for hisSong of Ice and Firebooks is almost unrecognizable from his end product. In it, Catelyn Stark didn’t die at the Red Wedding — but she still met a grim end.
There Was No Red Wedding In GRRM’s Original Plan
Robb Stark Died On The Battlefield Instead
The reason Catelyn didn’t die at the Red Wedding in Martin’s initialSong of Ice and Fireplan is that the incident didn’t exist. This seems to be a twist Martin came up with later, though he always intended for Robb and Catelyn to die. In the author’s original outline,Robb perished on the battlefield instead of at the Red Wedding. In some ways, it’s a fitting fate for the character, who becomes cocky after racking up a number of wins against the Lannisters. And Robb would have harmed Joffrey in the process, allowing him to deliver some retribution for Ned’s execution.
George R.R. Martin’s Original A Song Of Ice & Fire Plan Would’ve Avoided Game Of Thrones' Biggest Ending Problem
George R.R. Martin’s original plan for his A Song of Ice and Fire series would have solved one of Game of Thrones’ biggest ending problems.
However, it’s perhaps more fitting that Robb’s diplomatic shortcomings result in his downfall instead. And it’s so much more tragic that his mother is present for his death, raising the emotional stakes of the Red Wedding.Catelyn didn’t accompany Robb as he went to war in Martin’s original outline, meaning she wouldn’t witness his death or die alongside him. She also wouldn’t become theundead and vengeful Lady Stoneheart, a development that only exists in theASOIAFbooks — but with Martin’s initial plans for Catelyn, it almost didn’t happen at all.
How Catelyn Died In GRRM’s Original Plan & Why It Means No Lady Stoneheart
She Perished North Of The Wall
With the Red Wedding not happening in Martin’s originalASOIAFplan, Catelyn died another way — and it happened North of the Wall. The books and TV show never took Catelyn there, but Martin’s outline saw Catelyn fleeing to the Wall on the heels of Ned’s death. She took Bran and Arya with her, presumably afraid of retaliation from the Lannisters. Unfortunately, Benjen wasn’t able to help her, so she wound up traveling beyond the Wall. This sealed Catelyn’s fate, asMartin intended for her to be killed by the Others.
Why A Song Of Ice & Fire’s Version Of The Night King Is Much Better Than Game Of Thrones' Villain
The Night’s King is A Song of Ice and Fire’s version of the Night King, and the character makes a better villain than his Game of Thrones counterpart.
Better known as the White Walkers inGame of Thrones,the Others are the real threat of Martin’s fantasy series. Catelyn’s initial demise would have highlighted how dangerous they really are. It also would have been a more gruesome end for her character than the one she eventually got. While the Red Wedding was devastating, it wasn’t totally surprising in a series so focused on human power struggles and evils.Tywin’s actions during Robert’s Rebellionmade it clear he’d go this far, and Catelyn’s death was quick. She also returned and took revenge on her enemies as Lady Stoneheart.
It might not have been quick, and it could even have seen Catelyn returning in an even worse way than she does inA Song of Ice and Fire.
By contrast, Catelyn’s originalSong of Ice and Firefate would have seen her dying afraid and in an unfamiliar place. She wouldn’t be expecting the Others, while she at least knew the risks she and Robb were taking with their war against the Lannisters. Her original death might not have been quick, and it could even have seen Catelyn returning in a worse way than she does inA Song of Ice and Fire.
Catelyn Stark Could’ve Returned In An Even Worse Way
Her Original Song Of Ice And Fire Death Could Have Made Her A Wight
If Catelyn Stark had been killed by the Others like Martin intended,she probably would have returned as a wight in the laterSong of Ice and Firebooks. This would arguably be worse than her Lady Stoneheart fate, as it could result in her attacking her own children. Lady Stoneheart only seeks vengeance against those responsible for the Red Wedding, but having Catelyn become a wight would be heartbreaking for her and the rest of the Starks.
Why Game Of Thrones' Title Wasn’t “A Song Of Ice & Fire”
HBO decided to call its adaptation of George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire books by a different name, but how did it land on Game of Thrones?
It’s probably for the best that Martin didn’t go with this original plan for Catelyn Stark, and that’s true for many of the changes he made from his original outline. His willingness to shift his plans also resulted in the Red Wedding, which went down as one of the biggest moments inA Song of Ice and FireandGame of Thrones.It’s difficult to envision the books or show without it, a fact that further proves Martin made the right choice.
Game Of Thrones
Cast
Based on George R. R. Martin’s ongoing A Song of Ice and Fire novel series, Game of Thrones is a fantasy drama set in the fictional continents of Westeros and Essos. It follows noble families like the Starks, Lannisters, and Targaryen vying for control of the Iron Throne while a rising threat from the undead looms in the North. The series received significant critical success and amassed a loyal fan base due to its high production values, sprawling sets, iconic characters, and shocking twists.
Game of Thrones
Game of Thrones is a multimedia franchise created by George R.R. Martin. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire is the basis for the award-winning HBO series Game of Thrones, which lasted for eight seasons. After the incredibly divisive final season of Game of Thrones, the series was followed up by the prequel series House of the Dragon, which also received critical acclaim.
