This article contains SPOILERS for A Good Girl’s Guide To Muder.
Summary
A Good Girl’s Guide To Murdermakes adjustments to Sal Singh and Andie Bell’s relationship, giving the show a more tragic aspect than the book. InA Good Girl’s Guide To Murderbook,Sal and Andie are on the verge of breaking upbefore their disappearances and untimely deaths, pinpointing Sal as the prime suspect. There are also racially charged motivations behind the press’s coverage of Sal, exploring how ethnicity plays a part in unfair accusations. Unfortunately, Sal’s naiveté plays a part in his treatment, allowing Andie to indulge in her manipulative behavior.
Andie’s portrayal in the book casts her as an unsavory character, despite her unfortunate ending. While she could have a generous and good-natured side, Andie’s habit of exploiting people’s insecurities casts her as a morally complex character. She’s much more sensitive toward Sal, but her secrets from her illicit relationships and other activities threaten his safety and well-being. In many ways, Andie is a victim to her inner struggle and Sal is a victim to Andie’s decisions.Emma Myers' Netflix showdepicts their relationship in a different light, gaining more empathy for the couple’s love story.
A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder Soundtrack Guide: Every Song (& When They Play)
Netflix’s murder mystery A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder includes an eclectic soundtrack that shapes the plot and mood and enhances the show.
Netflix’s A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder Changes Sal & Andie’s Relationship For The Better
The Netflix Show Makes A Significant Change To Their Story
The show reveals that they were planning to run away together at the end right before their deaths, indicating they were hoping for a long-term future together. While the book expresses their relationship as fraught with tension, the show focuses on their genuine affection.Sal does his best to protect Andiefrom the consequences of her actions, adding an element of sympathy for Andie’s vulnerabilities. His protective nature towards Andie doesn’t go unnoticed, as demonstrated in a pivotal scene between the two.
In the scene during which the two are plotting to escape, it’s revealed that Andie has saved up her money to support their venture. Before this scene happens, it’s only told from ayoung Pip Fitz-Amobi’s point of view, but the interaction between Andie and Sal during those moments heightens the passion they feel for each other. In contrast to the books, their relationship inA Good Girl’s Guide To Murderis depicted as a “star-crossed lovers” dynamic. As a result,their romance is much more compelling and devastating than the original rendering of their characters.
A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder’s Sal & Andie Change Makes The Series More Tragic
Despite Andie’s nefarious hobbies, the show’s perspective of Andie and Sal makes it feel like they’re two young teenagers in love, simply looking for a way out of their oppressive environment. As Pip slowly unravels the true nature of their relationship, she comes to a deeper understanding of their desires to escape their real-life nightmares. Pip’s discovery reveals their true ambitions:Sal only wanted Andie to confront her demonsand leave her troubled past behind, and Andie wanted to be rescued from her life choices, making Sal’s wrongful accusations even more unjust and heartbreaking.
The differing viewpoints of Andie in the show describe why they function better as a couple than they do in the books.
The show documents the toll of the investigation on Sal’s mental health, uncovered in a video that Pip watches of a police interrogation with Sal. He’s not only faced with a permanently tarnished reputation but strains on his relationships and family members. His relationship with Andie isn’t perfect, but neither of them deserves intense scrutiny from their community, and Sal certainly doesn’t deserve to be framed for Andie’s murder. Their love for each other compounds the show’s catastrophe, andthe Netflix showhumanizes Andie in a way the books weren’t able to, going deeper into her struggles.
The Netflix Series Makes Multiple Changes To Andie Bell’s Character
The Show Takes Some Creative Liberties
The differing viewpoints of Andie in the show describe why they function better as a couple than they do in the books. She’s expected to maintain her popularity and status quo but is subjected to cruelty from characters like Becca Bell, Elliot Ward, and even her father. Her involvement with drug dealing is suggested to be a desperate response to all these social pressures, and she resorts to blackmailing as a cry for help rather than out of malicious intent. Instead of featuring her conniving qualities,Netflix’sA Good Girl’s Guide To Murderpresents Andie as a person dealing with loss.
Once Andie’s father steals her money, her familial problems are exposed and some of her actions finally have some explanation. There are very few people she can trust, and she is tossed around between characters as if she were an object. Andie has the potential to become greater than her circumstances through her relationship with Sal. Their love temporarily redeems her from the darkness surrounding her life. Their eventual fatalities complicate their relationship and, because of their characters' differences from the books, the misfortune of their deaths leaves a heavier emotional weight inA Good Girl’s Guide To Murder.
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
Cast
Pip Fitz-Amobi, a determined young investigator, is set on uncovering the truth behind schoolgirl Andie Bell’s murder five years prior. Sal Singh, Andie’s boyfriend, confessed before his own death, but Pip doesn’t believe he’s guilty. Teaming up with Sal’s brother Ravi, she dives into a web of secrets to find the real killer.
